So many last lines don't do anything at all. I suspect that many authors are afraid of being too obvious, or are trying to be artful. Or maybe writers just don't know when to quit.
~Donald Maass (who else? haha), The Fire In Fiction, p. 69
A good majority of writerly advice focuses on beginnings rather than endings. Which I find a bit misleading. Yes, beginnings are uber-important, but not disproportionately so to endings.
The way I see it, anyone can start a novel. Anyone can start a scene. But how many people can finish them? And not only finish them, but end them in a way that has impact on the reader.
The final words on a page are the ones that stick with the reader. Even more so than the words used to open a new scene, chapter, novel.
Take, for example, a scene I just randomly selected out of the novel Matched by Ally Condie. I opened the book and used whatever scene I'd opened to, and not surprisingly, since this is a very well-written novel, the scene I opened to proves my point.
Here is the first line:
"Someone said a girl your age came to the work site today," my father says.
This opening sets the stage for the scene that will unfold. It's a grounding point. Which is important, truly. But it isn't what the author wants you to really remember as you move forward through the story. She wants you to remember the final line:
I will try to forget that Ky said "home" when he looked into my eyes.
Does that not have more impact? Also noteworthy is that this line is clearly relevant to the novel's overall premise. This doesn't happen by accident. This author knows what she's doing. Her words don't just happen, they are created. Formed. They have purpose.
Final lines can make or break your story. They have the ability to change the reader's view, for better or worse, in as little time as it takes to read the sentence. I don't believe the same can be said of opening lines.
So in studying this, specifically, in a few of the novels I own, I then looked to my own work to see how I was doing in this particular area.
In a middle chapter of Social Graces I found this as the final line:
Or it might just be my stupidest idea yet.
The MC's whole life appears to be, to her, just a string of bad ideas and wrong choices. Ending on this thought entices the reader to keep going, to see if her idea this time will work or not. Will she fix anything, or just make it all worse? (for a middle scene, it should be the latter -- no real fixing of anything until the end)
Again from Social Graces:
I wish relationships were as easy to navigate as a map.
This finalizes the events of the scene (they are driving in the car, get in an argument, and get lost so they have to pull out the map), makes the point of the scene clear. It tells the reader, "This is why I included that scene, this is the point, this is why you should care." And it says all that without outright saying it. The sentence is just an observation made by the MC, a passing thought, yet it is relevant to both the individual scene and the overall premise of the novel. It reminds the reader why they started reading this story in the first place.
You can certainly end a scene or chapter on a life-or-death cliffhanger, but it is not always necessary to push a reader forward. In fact, to me, it feels gimmicky if a good percentage of the chapters end on a "scene cut." Don't overuse this technique. More effective (and less annoying) are subtle thrusters... little tugs that keep the reader turning pages without really knowing why.
Give your final lines more impact by keeping these points in mind:
1. Scenes and chapters have structure just like a full novel has structure. Create impact with circularity back to the opening lines.
2. Plant a seed of mystery. Plant a seed of doubt. Promise the reader something to discover by continuing on.
3. End on a new decision, a new viewpoint, a new conflict. In other words, end with a clear change in the MC's world, however subtle it may seem in the moment.
4. Connect the final words of a scene or chapter to the main premise in some way. This keeps the plot fluid and emphasizes your theme.
5. Less is more. A single sentence -- a succinct, direct observation -- can have worlds more impact than a full paragraph that details the same thought.
Can you think of any other ways to give final lines that extra oomph?
Happy writing,
~Lydia
I'm with you. I think the way we end a scene or chapter, or even a whole book, is vitally important.
ReplyDeleteI like to try and create some sense of "coming full circle," especially with my book endings. Not necessarily a mirror of the opening, but something that reminds the reader of what has gone before and what the protagonist has had to endure, while also showing how they're a better person for it.
You always have the best analysis of the most important aspects of writing and books.
ReplyDeleteNot necessarily for the final line of an entire novel, but for the last line of a scene, I like a strong, succinct sentence that begs more questions than any answers it might give.
I've learned so much about last lines and scene endings from my agent, who frequently suggested cutting my chapters about 2 paragraphs before I'd ended them. She really taught me to end in a way that makes the reader want to turn the page (and I'm still learning about it). This post is extremely useful in that regard. Thanks!
ReplyDeleteEndings are so tricky! Sometimes I'll know that I have the perfect last line for a chapter, but other times I'm left flailing a bit. And the final line of a book is so so difficult. I never nail it on the first try, and usually even after several tries I'm still not satisfied with it. Maybe over time I'll get better?
ReplyDeleteI am such a fan of Donald Maass--his advice is always spot on. Endings are so tricky because you want to give the reader something to chew on, but you don't want it to be too obvious or to vague. I rewrite the endings of scenes A LOT, and I always wind up completely redoing my novel endings until they're (hopefully) right. Thanks for the great tips!
ReplyDeleteEndings are so difficult for me, so thank you for the tips! I really need to reread my Donald Maas book. You've reminded me to remind my brother-in-law to get it back to me! Anyway, as far as endings go, frankly, they scare me worse than first lines. I'll take all the advice I can get, and I have none to give!
ReplyDeleteI wish I knew. I guess my chapter endings seem to lounge in the cliff-hanger area. I do most everything by feel. And lots and lots of beta testing! hehe
ReplyDeleteI've been told I' decent with chapter endings. But MS2 has the worst ending I can imagine. On character literally tells another, "You will pay!" CRINGE :(
ReplyDeleteNIce post.
This is interesting. I've always found 'last lines' to be ones that I am quite particular about. They have to feel right to me, a scene or a chapter, and indeed a book, can't be finished with just any old line (indeed, if it did, the scene often wouldn't feel 'finished'). I wonder now if I've been doing some of this intuitively. Looking at some of my last lines suggests maybe I have.
ReplyDelete